Stars: 4 out of 5
I love coming back to this world. It’s so rich and complex, and every book shows us a new facet of it. I feel like each book gives me more puzzle pieces to a giant picture that I’m assembling by reading the series.
In this book, we reconnect with Kai from Five Fathoms Deep, and she is away from her island in a city she doesn’t understand or particularly like, trying to help her estranged sister. Well, first Kai reluctantly meets with her sister and refuses to help her, but then she spends the rest of the book trying to rectify that error. I missed Kai. She is a very good character. She isn’t a Craftswoman, she doesn’t have much personal power. She is a priestess to idols made by men from scratch to store their soul stuff in. And very recently a real priestess to a new Goddess. She is out of her depth in this strange and broken city where the God Wars started, and where the first Craftsman is still frozen in time, dying but not dead, tearing the world apart.
I loved this city. Both the Alikand that was lovingly preserved in the books and stories of its citizens and the broken Dead City where the war was still being fought in infinity, with both sides endlessly dying but not quite dead. And the strange order of the squid city that was so foreign to both the other cities, but was necessary to keep the wound of the Dead City from destroying the rest of the world. I am happy that Kai found a solution that preserved Alikand in the end.
I have one issue with this book – it dragged a little bit in the beginning when the heist of the train was being organized. We spent too much time with Kai’s sister, and I didn’t particularly like her as a person. Yes, I understood her motivations by the end of the book, and I could even sympathize, but I still think she could have handled all of this better if she stepped on her pride and asked for help, instead of trying to play everyone around her. You could argue that she caused most of the problems she worked so hard to solve afterward.
I was happy to see Tara again since she is by far my favorite character in the series, but she doesn’t play a very big role here. She helped where she could, but was mostly relegated to the background. Which I understand. This is Kai’s book. And the Blue Lady’s, because she finally came into her full powers here. The Goddess of thieves and street children, and lost and forgotten people, the fleeing, the downtrodden. The one who ate the Wastes.
What I love the most about this series is that despite some horrible things that happen to the characters in the books, there is always a hopeful note in the end. Kai and her sister finally make peace, and the poppy fields around Alikand are blooming once more.
Onward to the next book in the series.